Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

About

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is a beachfront wedding caterer located in Cape May, New Jersey, housed in a Georgian Revival mansion directly on Beach Avenue. The venue combines fine dining service with oceanfront ceremony and reception spaces, offering couples a seaside setting for their celebration. The restaurant handles all catering in-house, drawing on its Zagat-recommended culinary approach. An onsite wedding coordinator works with couples throughout planning and execution, managing details alongside the dedicated catering and service staff. The team tailors menus and event flow to match each couple's preferences and vision. Wedding catering packages start at $2,000. Peter Shields Inn accommodates guests for both ceremonies and receptions, with the ocean providing the natural backdrop for celebrations. The venue includes onsite guest accommodations for out-of-town attendees.

Compare with other caterers in Cape May or across NJ.

What couples should know

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is one of caterers listed on Blu List in Cape May, NJ, where every published price is shown upfront and no vendor has paid for placement. Pricing starts at $2,000, which is rare in this category — most caterers hide their numbers until couples submit a form. Couples have rated Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant 5.00 across 3 reviews, aggregated from public sources. This listing was built from public sources and has not yet been claimed by the business; details may be slightly out of date until Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant verifies the page. Before booking any caterer, it's worth comparing two or three nearby caterers side-by-side on price, capacity, and review patterns rather than going on photos alone.

Highlights

Frequently asked questions